Works Council Elections 2022 - Challenge § 19 BetrVG, Nullity, Preliminary Injunction

 
 
 

 

 

 

According to § 13 of the Works Constitution Act (BetrVG), regular works council elections take place every 4 years, between March 1st and May 31st. The Works Constitution Act and the associated election regulations govern the formal principles for how a works council election is to be conducted. In principle, there is the

  • regular „normal election procedures“ for companies over a limit of 100 employees and the
  • Simplified election procedures, according to § 14a BetrVG, for „small businesses“ below this threshold.

The simplified election procedure was initially intended primarily for businesses with fewer than 50 employees and was meant to accelerate and simplify the rather complicated and formalized regular election procedure. The employee limit was recently raised to 100 employees.

The period of works council elections also means an increased workload for the labor courts. Works council elections are highly regulated from a formal standpoint. According to expert estimates, approximately 70–80% of works council elections contain formal errors. Essentially, there are two possible approaches here:

 

I. Measures after a works council election

Objection under Section 19 of the Works Constitution Act

The Works Constitution Act itself regulates the possibility of challenging the works council election in Section 19 BetrVG. According to this, the works council election can be challenged if essential provisions concerning the right to vote, eligibility, or the election procedure have been violated.

 

a) Persons entitled to challenge:

  • at least 3 eligible voters,
  • The trade union representing the company,
  • the employer.

b) Period for challenging a decision:

The challenge must be filed within two weeks of the announcement of the election results for the works council election.

c) Duration of legal proceedings:

The processing times at the labor courts vary. You can certainly expect a period of 2.5 years for proceedings before the labor court and the regional labor court.

d) Effect of the declaration of invalidity:

If the court legally determines that the election was invalid, this determination applies „ex nunc.“ This means that with the legally binding determination of the invalidity of the works council election, the works council office ends. All actions taken by the works council up to that point remain valid.

 

2. Determination of the nullity of the works council election

The nullity of the works council election can be asserted in court if „essential principles of electoral law have been violated to such a high degree that not even the appearance of a proper works council election remains.“.

a) Eligible for application:

„Anyone with a legitimate interest.“.
But for safety, the provisions of the challenge should also be observed.

b) Application deadline:

None in particular. But it should be noted in a timely manner that it is ineffective.

c) Duration of legal proceedings:

The processing times at the labor courts vary. A period of 2.5 years can certainly be factored in for proceedings before the Labor Court and the Regional Labor Court.

d) Effect of the declaration of election nullity:

If the court legally determines that the works council election was void, this determination applies „ex tunc.“ This means that the works council whose election was declared void never existed, with problematic consequences for all actions taken by the works council during that period, especially in the case of concluded works agreements.

 

II. Measures Before or During the Works Council Election

However, case law has also recognized that formal errors, including those during works council elections, can be challenged by those affected. The sources of error are diverse, for example:

  • Defective collection of support signatures
  • Rejection of candidate lists by the election committee
  • In the event of serious errors, the cancellation of the election may also be considered.

Procedure:

As a rule, these formal errors are asserted by way of a preliminary injunction because of the imminent works council election.

b) Duration of proceedings:

The load for the appointment and the duration of the proceedings are very short.

The Frankfurt Labour Court, for example, had made a decision at first instance on Friday, March 4, 2022, and served the written decision on the parties that same afternoon.
On Monday, March 7, 2022, the written appeal against the first-instance decision was filed, and the hearing before the Regional Labor Court took place on March 8, 2022.

In a separate proceeding, the Frankfurt Labor Court served the applicant's motion on the respondent on March 9, 2022, at approximately 12:00 PM and had already scheduled the oral hearing for March 10, 2022. During this time, the respondent had to prepare and submit their statement of defense to the court in such a way that the other parties still had an opportunity to take note of its contents.

But it can be even faster.
Receipt of written summons, Friday, March 11, 2022, 2:15 PM.
Hearing date Friday, March 11, 2022, 3:30 PM.

 

Recommendation

It is therefore advisable to prepare the works council election properly and to pay careful attention to all formalities when conducting the works council election.
However, it must also be stated that in most cases it will not be possible to conduct a works council election correctly without legal assistance.

 

Get in touch