In the course of the vaccination offer to combat the corona pandemic, the question of the legal permissibility of a vaccination status inquiry by the employer is dividing opinions. As long as a mandatory quarantine was ordered, employees received compensation. This applied regardless of vaccination status.
The situation has been different since September 22nd. As of November 2021, the Federal and State Ministries of Health will no longer reimburse unvaccinated individuals for loss of earnings. The reason given for this is the widespread availability of vaccination.
Currently, public health authorities are not verifying the requirements for eligibility for compensation payments in the event of an official quarantine order. This presents employers with a series of labor law questions regarding continued wage payment and vaccination status inquiries.
The most important points in brief
- A claim for compensation under Section 56 (1) sentences 4 and 5 of the IfSG does not exist if the employee could have avoided the quarantine by receiving a generally recommended vaccination.
- Questions concerning the practical implementation of continued wage payments under Section 56 of the IfSG remain in need of clarification due to a lack of a clear legal situation.
- The employer may not inquire about the immunization status of employees in general, but only in connection with employment in the healthcare sector.
- The State Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information of Baden-Württemberg has compiled a set of points that serve as a guideline for the processing of personal data. There is potential for conflict with the responsible authorities here.
Infection Protection Act Vaccination Status Inquiry
As the vaccination campaign progresses, not only health law but also labor law questions arise. For example, an employer's potential right to inquire about the vaccination status of their employees is at the center of legal discussions. According to §§ 23a, 36 IfSG, the employer may process personal data of an employee regarding their vaccination status, to the extent necessary to fulfill obligations under § 23 (3) IfSG, in order to decide on the establishment of an employment relationship.
The mandatory program under Section 23, Paragraph 3 of the Infection Protection Act (IfSG) states that the heads of medical facilities, such as hospitals, doctor's offices, or nursing services, must ensure that the measures required by the current state of medical science are taken to prevent infections and avoid the further spread of pathogens.
This represents the statutory authorization for medical professional groups, as vaccination data is considered health data according to Art. 4 No. 15 GDPR, which is therefore particularly deserving of protection under Art. 9 GDPR. Furthermore, Art. 9 para. 2 lit. b) GDPR must be observed for all others.
This is only permitted if the indication is necessary for the employer or the employed person to be able to exercise their rights and fulfill their obligations arising from labor law and social security and social protection law.
A necessity can only be assumed if the data is indispensable for the performance of tasks within the scope of the activity.
This is again the case where the task cannot be fulfilled without knowledge of the information, not in a timely manner, or only with disproportionate effort. Therefore, for the necessity to be affirmed in the present case, the employer must be absolutely unable to organize their business or fulfill their obligations without information about vaccination status.
Compensation under the Infection Protection Act
§ 56 of the IfSG states: „Anyone who, based on this law, is subject to or is subjected to prohibitions in the exercise of their previous occupation as an excretor, suspected of being infected, suspected of having an illness, or otherwise a carrier of pathogens within the meaning of Section 31, Sentence 2, and thereby suffers a loss of earnings, shall receive monetary compensation.".
Monetary compensation may also be granted to a person if they have already taken precautionary isolation or have voluntarily refrained from pursuing certain professional activities, in whole or in part, before the order for isolation according to § 30 or a professional ban according to § 31 was issued, and consequently suffered a loss of earnings, if an order for isolation according to § 30 or a professional ban according to § 31 could have been issued at the time of the precautionary isolation or the precautionary non-employment.“
Compensation cannot be paid to a person under sentences 1 and 2 if they could have avoided a prohibition in the exercise of their previous occupation or a quarantine by undergoing a vaccination that is legally required or publicly recommended in their usual place of residence, or by not undertaking an avoidable trip to a risk area that was already classified as such at the time of departure. If a quarantine order is issued against an employee, the employer shall initially continue to pay wages for up to six weeks.
The employer makes this payment as a representative „on behalf of the competent authority.“ In a second step, the employer can then demand reimbursement of the amounts paid from the competent authority. In any case, a claim does not exist pursuant to Section 56 (1) sentences 4 and 5 of the IfSG if the quarantine could have been avoided.
If employees travel to countries that may result in a quarantine, they are acting culpably in the sense of the continued remuneration provisions if they actually have to go into quarantine upon their return. As a consequence of such behavior on the part of the employee, there is a temporary impediment to the provision of services in accordance with Section 616 of the German Civil Code (BGB). Accordingly, there is no claim for continued remuneration in such a case.
If the employee has the possibility to perform their work from home during the quarantine phase, their entitlement to remuneration naturally remains.
Statements of the State Commissioner for Data Protection of Baden-Württemberg
The Conference of Health Ministers decided that unvaccinated individuals can no longer claim compensation during quarantine. Since the processing of compensation payments according to Section 56, Paragraph 5, Sentence 1 of the IfSG initially goes through the employer, the question now arises as to whether the employer is allowed to ask about vaccination status in order to assess how they should proceed.
The State Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information of Baden-Württemberg commented on this. However, there is not complete agreement with the responsible authorities on all points: „Fundamentally, employers are already prohibited from asking questions about private or special categories of personal data according to Art. 9 GDPR (health data according to Art. 4 No. 15 GDPR, for example).".
However, in connection with the payment of compensation under Section 56 of the IfSG, there are sufficient legal indications that the employer is assigned a role in this matter that can justify such a question. While the employer may inquire about the employee's vaccination status in the context of wage reimbursement, the employee is not obliged to disclose their sensitive data if they do not wish to do so.
According to the LfDI, the employee can, for example, also ensure continued payment of wages through the responsible regional council without the employer gaining knowledge of the health data. The responsible authorities see this differently. „Such differing views are problematic for both employers and employees, and ultimately only the legislature can provide clarity.“
Data Processing for a Quarantine Order
What ultimately needs to be considered in data processing in connection with quarantine is compiled by the LfDI BaWü in a catalog. This refers to points that must be observed when processing personal data in relation to compensation payments:
- The employer may inquire about the vaccination status of employees if they are paying compensation to the authority.
- The employee is not obligated according to Art. 9 para. 2 lit. b) GDPR to disclose their vaccination status or other health data to the employer. This merely addresses the employer's processing powers, but not any disclosure obligations of the employee. While the employee can freely decide whether to provide the employer with personal information for the reimbursement claim according to § 56 para. 5 sentence 3 IfSG, they run the risk of suffering disadvantages due to a lack of cooperation.
- If the employee discloses personal data to the employer for the reimbursement claim according to § 56 (5) sentence 3 IfSG, this is done within the scope of explicit consent according to the GDPR. The information must be provided by the employee on a voluntary basis. In this context, voluntariness requires that the employer always gives the employee the choice to provide the necessary information to them. They must be well-informed about the purposes of use by the employer (Art. 4 No. 11 GDPR) and about the possibility of revoking consent to the use of their data (Art. 7 (3) sentence 3 GDPR).
- The data is subject to strict purpose limitation. After the employer has used it to obtain reimbursement of their compensation payment, they must immediately delete this data.
- According to the State Commissioner for Data Protection, the employee always has the option to request compensation from the competent authority himself pursuant to § 56 (5) sentence 4 IfSG, instead of providing information to his employer. However, the competent authorities deny the employee's own right to apply. The employee must disclose his vaccination status to the employer, but not the reasons against vaccination. The authorities are of the opinion that the employee can only submit his own application for periods of isolation from the 7th week onwards. Such long periods of isolation do not regularly occur with Corona.
Outlook
The legal situation is unclear and disputed in this regard. This creates significant potential for conflict and legal uncertainty. From a data protection perspective, employers generally do not have access to their employees' health data.
Financial disadvantages must be accepted by the employer unavoidable thus far. Data protection supervisory authorities have indeed shown a willingness during the course of the pandemic to observe the specific characteristics of the pandemic in data protection assessments.
It has not yet been clarified by the courts whether employers are permitted to obtain information about the vaccination status of their employees who are not in the healthcare sector. The necessity according to Art. 9 Para. 2 lit. b) GDPR must be denied in most cases.
The opinions available regarding compensation for quarantine are too sparse to make definitive statements about the admissibility of querying vaccination status to clarify compensation payments. Further case law is still awaited on this point.