Termination for insult on WhatsApp

In our daily consulting practice, we repeatedly encounter situations involving defamatory statements and images that have been disseminated via messenger services (e.g., WhatsApp, Viber).

However, what happens if this content is passed on to third parties, for example, to the employer?

Insulting one's employer, colleagues, or making xenophobic remarks in the workplace constitutes a significant breach of the contractual duty of consideration pursuant to § 241 of the German Civil Code (BGB) arising from the employment relationship and can itself form an important reason for an extraordinary termination.

However, the Federal Labor Court (BAG) already stated in a ruling in 2009 that the circumstances under which the statement in question was made must be taken into account in the legal assessment. If this occurred within the context of an emotionally charged dispute, it cannot, without further ado, justify the termination of the employment relationship.

Confidential statements fall within the scope of protection afforded by the general right of personality.

In a matter before the Rhineland-Palatinate Regional Labor Court in 2015, the employee who was later terminated stated to a colleague via text message that the boss was and would remain an „autistic sick asshole...“.

This SMS was forwarded by the employee who was contacted to the said „boss,“ who then issued an immediate termination.

The Mainz Labor Court had to decide a case in 2017 in which four employees made xenophobic remarks and shared corresponding images in their own WhatsApp group. The employer became aware of this and terminated the employment of the four employees without notice.

All proceedings have been ruled in favor of the terminated employees. The terminations were ineffective in all cases (e.g., Labor Court Mainz, judgment of November 15, 2017 – Case No.: 4 Ca 1240/17).

Confidentiality of words, even within a (manageable) „group.“

Defamatory, slanderous, or xenophobic remarks made only in a confidential conversation or a limited WhatsApp group may not, under certain circumstances, justify extraordinary termination of the employment relationship, nor ordinary termination. Confidential communication in private life is an expression of personality and is protected by fundamental rights. Employees may generally expect that their statements will not be disclosed externally, will not disturb the peace of the workplace, and will not destroy the trust relationship.

As early as 1965, the Federal Labor Court assumed that such statements, if made within a circle of colleagues, are made with the secure expectation that they will not go beyond the circle of conversation partners.

However, if the other party to the conversation or a participant in the group breaches confidentiality, this generally does not prejudice the employee legally. Even if it were attributable to the employee, the principle of proportionality must be observed. If the breach of contract is based on controllable behavior, it can be assumed that his future behavior can be positively influenced by threatening consequences for the existence of the employment relationship. Taking into account the principle of proportionality applicable in labor law, such behavior may at least justify a warning.

However, the above-mentioned facts would have to be evaluated differently if the employee himself terminates the confidentiality of the „conversation“ (e.g., by posting the defamatory statements on his Facebook wall, which colleagues also have access to), so that the opportunity for third parties to perceive his statements is attributable to him (ArbG Hagen (Westfalen), judgment of May 16, 2012 - file no.: 3 Ca 2597/11).

Tip:

As an employee, you should be very careful about what content is sent via SMS, WhatsApp, etc., and discussed in groups. Labor judges have also pointed out that due to the possibility of „sharing,“ no one can rely on confidentiality and the manageable size of the group. With just one „click,“ countless contacts can become aware of the sensitive content. Therefore, it's better not to discuss sensitive topics about the employer or colleagues via social media/messenger services.

Do you need legal advice in employment law? We are happy to advocate for your case. Register now for an initial consultation with one of our Specialist lawyers for labor law.

Get in touch