In recent years, video conferencing services have increasingly come under the scrutiny of data protection authorities. In the age of digitalization, these tools are now indispensable in professional life. The corona pandemic, in particular, was a driving factor for the demand for video conferencing services in recent years. However, with regard to the processing of personal data, these services have repeatedly raised data protection questions and uncertainties. In her 27th Activity Report of June 29, 2022, for the year 2021, the State Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information of North Rhine-Westphalia (LDI NRW), Bettina Gayk, highlighted that with the entry into force of the amendments to the Telecommunications Act (TKG), video conferencing systems are no longer classified as telemedia services, but as telecommunications services. This circumstance, among other things, means that concluding data processing agreements between users and providers of such services is no longer required. This not only has implications for accountability under Art. 4 No. 7 GDPR, but more importantly, also for supervisory authority jurisdiction.
The most important points in brief
- The concept of telecommunication services in the TKG is now significantly broadened, so that video conferencing systems are no longer considered telemedia services but rather telecommunication services.
- Following the assessment of the LDI, public bodies and companies using third-party video conferencing systems are no longer „controllers“ within the meaning of Article 4 No. 7 GDPR.
- Therefore, there is no longer a data processing agreement relationship between the video conferencing service provider and the user.
- The requirement for an order processing agreement pursuant to Art. 28 para. 3 GDPR between the parties shall not apply to this extent.
- The Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information is then the competent authority instead of the respective state data protection authority.
Entry into force of the TTDSG and amendments to the TKG
The TTDSG was enacted to implement the ePrivacy Directive and came into force on December 1, 2021. This law merged the data protection provisions of the Telemedia Act (TMG) and the Telecommunications Act (TKG). The goal of the law is to transfer the special statutory regulations on data protection contained in the TKG and TMG into a standalone law that is consistent with European requirements.
At the same time, largely unnoticed, amendments were made to the TKG, and the scope of telecommunications law was significantly expanded. The scope now includes not only telecommunications services that are number-bound (classic telephony) but also number-independent services (so-called OTT services/interpersonal communication). Telecommunications services are therefore services such as those offered by operators of messengers, video conferencing, and web-based email services. In contrast, providers of telemedia are those who provide content on the internet.
Previous data protection situation
Data protection authorities have been intensely focused on data protection issues related to the use of video conferencing services in recent years. Especially during the COVID-19 pandemic, video conferencing services became essential for communication. Companies and other organizations had to react quickly to this situation and often lacked their own conferencing platforms. Consequently, third-party services, such as Zoom or Microsoft Teams, were frequently used. In such cases, according to the Conference of Independent Data Protection Supervisory Authorities of the Federal and State Governments (DSK), there was a data processing agreement within the meaning of Art. 28 GDPR between the company or public body (user) and the video conferencing service provider (e.g., Zoom). In this scenario, the company or public body acted as the „controller“ as defined in Art. 4(7) GDPR, and the video conferencing service acted as the "processor" as defined in Art. 4(8) GDPR.
The basis of the order processing relationship is a contract between the controller and the order processor within the meaning of Art. 28 para. 3 GDPR, which binds the order processor with regard to the controller's instructions. In terms of content, this should include the subject matter and duration of the processing, the nature and purpose of the processing, the type of personal data, the categories of data subjects, and the duties and rights of the controller. The DSK also pointed out that when selecting the order processor, the controller must ensure that the processor provides sufficient guarantees regarding the required technical and organizational measures.
Even with regard to liability for data protection violations, there are some special features in a contract processing relationship. This is because Art. 82 GDPR provides for joint liability of the contract processor and the controller towards the data subject for material and also non-material damages.
Data protection implications of the changes
According to the assessment of the State Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information and the definition of „interpersonal telecommunication services“ in Section 3 No. 24 of the German Telecommunications Act (TKG), video conferencing services are no longer considered telemedia services but are classified as telecommunication services. This is because the definition of telecommunication services in the TKG has been broadened. This also has consequences under data protection law.
Firstly, users of video conferencing systems, who use them in their companies or public authorities, are regularly no longer to be regarded as data controllers. This circumstance, in turn, means that there is no order processing and the service provider acts on their own responsibility. Accordingly, the conclusion of an order processing contract is no longer required in this regard. According to the LDI, such a contract is only necessary if further services are offered or used that go beyond mere communication. However, the report also emphasizes that companies and public authorities are still obliged to take technical and organizational measures. In particular, this refers to the users' obligation to make basic data protection settings.
Furthermore, there is a shift in supervisory responsibilities. The Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information (BfDI) is now responsible for video conferencing systems that are to be understood as telecommunications services, such as Google Meet, Microsoft Teams, or Zoom, and no longer the responsible state data protection authorities.
European Data Protection Board (EDPB): Telecommunications service providers are controllers under Art. 4 No. 7 GDPR
The accountability of telecommunications service providers has already been confirmed by the European Data Protection Board. In its Guidelines (07/2020 on the concepts of controller and processor in the GDPR), it classifies telecommunications service providers as controllers within the meaning of the GDPR when providing their electronic communication services. According to the EDPB, the provider of such services is generally considered the controller for the processing of personal data that is necessary for the operation of the service as such. The data protection provisions to be observed by them will then be largely based on the new TTDSG.
Uncertainty persists
The report from the State Commissioner again confirms the importance of the TKG amendments for handling video conferencing systems, but still leaves some questions unanswered and does not further specify some important terms. In particular, it remains unclear which specific data is processed „due to the transmission of the video chat“ according to the LDI, for which the user is then no longer responsible. It also remains open what exactly is meant by „video chat.“ However, the most relevant issue for practical purposes is likely the open question of how to handle functions of video conferencing systems that go beyond the mere transmission of communication itself. It remains questionable whether these are considered part of the telecommunications service or whether they are subject to GDPR. As long as these questions are not clarified, it may be useful in individual cases to continue concluding data processing agreements in order to avoid being accused of GDPR-violating processing at the end. For a legally compliant approach, intensive review and assessment on a case-by-case basis is therefore definitely required.
Conclusion
Within the framework of the TKG amendment, which came into force on December 1, 2021, so-called OTT services or interpersonal communication such as video conferencing services now fall under the definition of telecommunications services and are no longer considered telemedia. This also has data protection consequences. However, it is doubtful whether it can be recommended so sweepingly that no order processing agreements are still required for video conferencing services. This is because it is controversial to what extent order processing agreements must continue to be concluded if the services go beyond mere communication. In this regard, the LDI NRW report points in a direction where many questions remain unanswered. Where are the boundaries drawn? What specific data is processed „due to the transmission of the video chat“ and what exactly are „video chats“ anyway? Are the functions of such a service that go beyond the communication process part of the telecommunications service or are they subject to the provisions of the GDPR? From a legal perspective, this classification is of great importance. For this reason, users should be cautious with special tools or functions of video conferencing providers and, if they use them, better double-check the data protection implications. Companies and public bodies using such video conferencing services are therefore advised to individually assess whether order processing agreements should not still be concluded until all open questions are clarified. It remains to be seen how these issues will be answered in the future. This would be of particular urgency, especially in view of the great uncertainty surrounding the use of video conferencing services overall.