Ineffective consent for profiling

 
 
 

 

 

 

Facts

In August 2016, the plaintiff suffered a severe traffic accident, after which she hired the defendant as her legal counsel on September 8, 2016, to handle the accident damages. Furthermore, the defendant represented the plaintiff in a claim against the liability insurer of a beauty salon from 2017.

On January 7, 2020, the plaintiff terminated the mandate relationship and demanded from the defendant complete data disclosure in accordance with Article 15 GDPR and the handover of a copy of the case file. This file is a compilation of all documents collected and belonging to a specific legal case.

The defendant was nine months late in providing the data disclosure, and the claim was not fully satisfied. Information about the mandate account was missing, as were reports of communication via email and WhatsApp between the plaintiff and the defendant. Furthermore, it is unclear whether data was passed on to another attorney who shared an office with the defendant and used the same fax number.

The plaintiff was therefore compelled to engage another attorney, which incurred further costs that she sought to recover. She described the defendant's conduct as vexatious, as he not only provided significantly delayed but, above all, incomplete data disclosure.

Finally, information regarding the proceedings against the cosmetic studio is still missing. Due to the delayed data disclosure, the plaintiff was unable to assert claims against the insurance company.

In this context, the plaintiff additionally claimed non-material damages under Art. 82 GDPR, which should not be less than €1,000. The delay and the imputed willfulness were cited as justification for the non-material damage.

The „Jö Bonus Club“ initiated by REWE Austria is to pay a 2 million euro fine for inducing users to use personal data for advertising purposes in the form of profiling, through a misleadingly formatted registration form. The registered customers assumed they were only signing up for the bonus club itself. This is according to the decision of the Austrian Data Protection Authority published on August 2, 2021.

In data protection law, the principle is: The processing of personal data is prohibited unless the law provides an exception or the data subjects consent. However, obtaining voluntary and informed consent from customers, as required by law, is an institution that is often circumvented and sometimes ignored by companies in practice. As a result, it frequently happens that customers have not even consented to data processing in the first place, have been literally pressured, or, in the course of obfuscation tactics, did not know what they were actually consenting to.

 

The most important things in brief:

  • The processing of personal data is subject to a prohibition with an exception, Art. 6(1) sentence 1 GDPR.
  • 7 sec. 2 GDPR regulates the requirements for valid consent. Accordingly, it must be made understandable and transparent to the data subject what data processing they are consenting to.
  • When profiling for needs-based advertising, the framework of Article 22 GDPR must be observed from a data protection perspective, and particular caution is advised.
  • Consent forms that are not written in a clear and understandable manner are invalid and cannot be used as a legal basis.
  • In connection with misleading approximately 2.3 million people, Jö Bonus Club GmbH has now received a fine of 2 million euros.

 

Background

The basis for the fine imposed was insufficient consent during registration for the so-called Jö Bonus Club in Austria. Jö Bonus Club GmbH is part of the Rewe Austria supermarket chain. Similar to PayPal, the Jö Bonus Club is a customer loyalty program. By registering, members agreed not only to participate in the Bonus Club but also, among other things, to the use of their personal data for profiling purposes.

Profiling involves creating individual customer profiles to ultimately identify a tailored advertising package for each individual customer and then target them with advertising based on personal preferences and needs. The Austrian Data Protection Authority stated that the consents obtained from customers for profiling during the period from May 2019 to March 2020 are invalid.

This concerns the consents of a total of around 2.3 million individuals. The reason for this was the design of the consent process for the Jö Bonus Club. Since the information on additional data processing was only visible further down and therefore difficult to access, the data protection authority objected to the placement of the consent checkbox with regard to the data protection information. This led to potential members consenting with the intention of being able to benefit from exclusive advantages and promotions, rather than being informed about the further data processing at the aforementioned location.

Visitors could not discern that the consent also served for data processing for profiling purposes. Thus, any profiling activities were effectively concealed. On the paper registration forms as well, simultaneous consent for profiling purposes could not be immediately recognized by potential members. The way the consent was designed rather gave the impression that it was solely for registration in the Bonus Club itself, whereas in reality, consent for profiling was also obtained.

 

Consent and data protection

Obtaining consent can be a tricky matter for many companies due to carelessness or a lack of data protection awareness, and errors can lead to high fines. A lack of consent or invalid consent is not a minor offense.

Thus, AOK Baden-Württemberg had to pay a fine of 1.2 million euros. The consent of the customers was not unequivocally given in some cases, and AOK processed the data anyway. The Sparkasse also obtained consent from its customers through questionable means. Here, customers were induced to consent to data processing by exerting pressure.

A key consideration in the processing of personal data is consent within the meaning of Article 6(1)(a) of the GDPR, as data protection law operates on the principle of a general prohibition subject to specific exceptions. This means that data processing is, in principle, prohibited. If there is a legal exception or consent from the data subject for the respective processing, then data processing is permitted. Furthermore, the requirements of Article 7 of the GDPR must not be disregarded.

Article 7, Paragraph 2 of the GDPR stipulates that information about intended data processing must be provided to the data subject in a particularly understandable and easily accessible manner *before* they give their consent. Only then will it be possible for data subjects to make a free decision about the processing of their data. Therefore, the declaration and the entire consent process itself must be unambiguous for the data subject.

This is also laid down separately in Recital 32 of the GDPR: „Consent should be given by any unambiguous, freely given, specific, informed and explicit indication of the data subject's wishes by which he or she, by a statement or by a clear affirmative action, signifies agreement to the processing of personal data relating to him or her, such as by a written statement, including by electronic means, or an oral statement.“

 

Profiling activities as a marketing measure

Profiling involves the creation of individual customer profiles. This ensures that marketing efforts are targeted and tailored to customers' needs, with the aim of influencing purchasing decisions.

According to Article 4(4) of the GDPR, profiling means any form of automated processing of personal data consisting of the use of such personal data to evaluate certain personal aspects relating to a natural person, in particular to evaluate aspects concerning work performance, economic situation, health, personal preferences, interests, reliability, behavior, location, or movements of that natural person. The narrow legal framework for profiling is set forth in Article 22(1) of the GDPR.

Thereafter, the affected person has the right „not to be subject to a decision based solely on automated processing, including profiling, which produces legal effects concerning him or her or similarly significantly affects him or her.“

According to the responsible authority, more attention should have been paid to the information about data processing during profiling due to the increased risk.

 

The decision of the Austrian Data Protection Authority

The Austrian authority recognized in these incidents a violation of the club's duty to present its request for consent in an understandable and easily accessible form, using clear and simple language. Accordingly, the authority deemed the customers' consents invalid and the profiling conducted on that basis unlawful. This violation has previously been the subject of proceedings against the company. In response to this, the company had previously made changes to its consent declarations.

Instead of creating a new, proper consent for profiling and obtaining lawful consent from data subjects and existing customers, Jö Bonus Club GmbH continued to process the already unlawfully obtained data – without valid consent.

The Austrian Data Protection Authority imposed a fine of over 2 million euros. The authority took the effects of the Corona pandemic into account as a mitigating factor in determining the fine due to the fact that the COVID-19 pandemic complicated business activities and the club suffered losses. An appeal has since been lodged with the Federal Administrative Court. A decision from the court is still pending.

 

Outlook

Processing personal data for marketing purposes offers enormous potential for increasing companies' sales. A highly targeted advertising approach to potential customers plays a crucial role in this. However, such measures – and especially data-intensive profiling for marketing purposes – absolutely require the consent of the data subjects.

Disclosing to potential customers that these personal profiles are created in order to show them more targeted advertising may deter them and discourage them from giving their consent. It is therefore not surprising that companies often attempt to obtain consent by skillfully placing legally binding notices, without the user being aware of what they are actually consenting to.

This phenomenon is also particularly observable in the design of cookie consent managers. There, users are often persuaded through the use of so-called „dark patterns,“ in the form of deliberately chosen design and placement of buttons, to consent to more data processing than is technically necessary. European data protection authorities are also becoming increasingly active due to the use of such „dark patterns.“ The situation here is similar. 

By the way the privacy policy was worded, the club gave the impression that customers were signing up solely for discounts and coupons. Only if they scrolled down would they have learned that they were consenting to so-called profiling—that is, the use of their personal data to make future predictions.

However, the specific case shows that corresponding behavior does not necessarily pay off.

The company had to stop profiling customers who gave their consent during the affected period between May 2019 and March 2020. To prevent in advance that the hoped-for legal basis for processing turns out to be invalid and data processing is not possible despite obtaining consent, a comprehensive review should therefore be conducted before obtaining consent to ensure all requirements for its validity are met.

Given the complexity of the matter, it is advisable to Data Protection Officer to consult them at an early stage and involve them in such projects. The intended data processing must always be described in advance in a way that is easily understandable, transparent, and clear. If the requirements of Article 7(2) of the GDPR are not met, any company—similar to the Jö Bonus Club—risks a heavy fine due to data processing without a legal basis.

 

Get in touch