ECJ: Cookies only with consent

 
 
 
 

Introduction

Following its decision to use social media plugins, e.g., the Facebook Like Button, the CJEU once again made a groundbreaking decision concerning the use of (marketing and advertising) cookies.

The decision, which appears impractical and cumbersome for website operators and visitors alike, originates from the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), which has been in effect since May 25, 2018, and is dogmatically difficult to fault.

The CJEU decision of October 1, 2019 – Case C-673/17

The underlying facts are remarkably simple and probably known to everyone:

A website operator used various cookies on their website to analyze user behavior and, with the help of cooperation and advertising partners, create personalized and interest-based advertising. The website visitor or user had to interact with a cookie banner upon their (first) visit to the website.

The banner contained, among other things, an information text in which the participant agreed to the use of cookies that would evaluate their browsing and usage behavior and generate interest-based advertising. Next to this information text was a checkbox with a pre-filled tick (for the declaration of this consent). The ECJ recognized this practice of obtaining consent as unlawful.

He explained that consent (under data protection law) can only be assumed if there is an active expression of will from the person making the declaration, in this case, the website visitor. This can therefore only be affirmed when the website visitor actively checks a box.

Accordingly, a „[...] Silence, already ticked boxes, or inaction [...].“ constitute valid consent from the website visitor. However, this is precisely the case when „… the user must deselect a pre-checked box to refuse consent…“, why no valid consent can be assumed in the case of pre-ticked checkboxes.

Furthermore, the ECJ explained that consent is also always linked to the fact that „the user has given their consent on the basis of clear and comprehensive information, including information about the purposes of the processing. The clear and comprehensive information must enable the user to easily determine the consequences of any consent given by them and must ensure that consent is given with full knowledge of the facts. Information on the functional duration of cookies and whether third parties can access the cookies are part of the clear and comprehensive information that the service provider must provide to the user of a website.“.

This means that the submission of consent must always be preceded by comprehensive and explicit instruction or information of the website visitor, in which the use of cookies, the handling of their personal data, and the (legal) consequences of their consent are explained. Interference with the privacy (of the website visitor) through the creation of any usage profiles based on consent is only justified if the website visitor is aware of the scope of their declaration, according to the ECJ.

The outlook

As already explained, the CJEU's decision is truly revolutionary and alters the current practice of website operators.

Whereas in the past, website operators either used pre-checked boxes or based the use of cookies on a legitimate interest (and thus did not see the need to obtain consent from the website visitor), from now on there is a legal obligation for the previous cookie banners to be changed so that the user can opt in to the use of cookies active must confirm. Furthermore, he is before submission of Consent to transparently explain which cookies are used for what purpose.

In times when e-commerce is flourishing and a website serves as an entrepreneur's flagship, special care is urgently required when using cookies, obtaining consent, and adequately informing customers or website users.

Do you need legal advice on data protection law? We would be happy to represent your interests. Register now for an initial consultation with one of our Data Protection Lawyers.

 
 
 
Get in touch