The mere fear of potentially contracting the coronavirus when leaving the apartment is not sufficient reason for you to stay away from work. This is because a merely potential risk of infection is part of the general risks of life, which you must bear.
As far as your employment contract allows you to work from home (home office), this is not a problem. If your employment contract does not provide for a corresponding home office agreement, a supplementary agreement with the employer is possible. However, you may not make the decision yourself unless this is unequivocally stated in the employment contract. In case of doubt, clarification should be sought with the employer.
It is debated whether your employer can require you to work from home without a corresponding contractual agreement (through the exercise of their management rights). In any event, they are then obliged to provide the necessary work equipment (such as a company laptop, remote access to the company's IT infrastructure, etc.) so that you can perform your work; furthermore, your employer must comply with the relevant data protection regulations for home office work.
Please note:
If you do not go to work solely because of the abstract fear that you might become infected (on the way), you will lose your claim to remuneration. You generally bear the so-called travel risk, which means your claim to remuneration ceases to exist according to § 326 (1) of the German Civil Code (BGB) if you do not start your work in violation of your contractual obligation. Furthermore, you would also be absent without excuse. A general right to refuse performance according to §§ 273, 275 (3) BGB does not necessarily exist even in the event of impending pandemics. Absence could, in the worst case, lead to a warning or termination.
If you, in turn, have a justified suspicion (e.g., due to symptoms or contact with an infected person) that you have been infected with the coronavirus, the legal situation is different. This is because if a so-called temporary personal impediment exists (cf. § 616 Sentence 1 of the German Civil Code - BGB), you may stay away from work and will still receive your salary, provided this has not been excluded by a collective agreement or employment contract. This impediment exists, among other things, in the case of a medically necessary doctor's visit if it can only take place during working hours. If staying away from work is necessary for the medical clarification of a corona suspicion, the employer must be informed immediately about being away from work. You should also get written confirmation from the doctor or another place visited that there was a medical indication for the examination. You are not obligated to tell your employer the exact reason for the doctor's visit – i.e., the illness to be clarified.
As long as you have symptoms of illness and are unable to work as a result, you have the right to stay away from work due to your incapacity to work. You must inform your employer immediately of your incapacity to work, even in the case of a COVID-19 infection. Regardless of this, the law stipulates that an medical certificate – i.e., a certificate of incapacity for work – must be submitted to your employer no later than the third day of incapacity for work. Please always note whether a shorter deadline has been agreed upon in your employment or collective bargaining agreement. As long as you are ill, you are generally entitled to continued remuneration from your employer for a period of six weeks in accordance with Section 3 of the Continued Remuneration Act (EFZG) and subsequently to sickness benefit from your health insurance fund.
If a (governmental) employment ban according to § 31 IfSG and/or quarantine according to § 30 IfSG is imposed simultaneously due to the coronavirus infection, you are entitled to compensation according to § 56 para. 1 IfSG instead of § 3 EFZG due to the ban on activities or quarantine. The employer will make advance payments and pay you compensation equal to the contractually agreed remuneration. The amounts paid out will be reimbursed to the employer by the competent authority upon request, see § 56 para. 5 sentence 2 IfSG. However, reimbursement will only be made upon your employer's application. If the employer does not make advance payments despite the legal obligation, you can also file this application according to § 56 para. 5 sentence 3 IfSG.
Yes, because the employer, according to § 613 Sentence 3 of the German Civil Code (BGB), fundamentally bears the economic risk associated with the company and ultimately the realization of your work performance.
If your employer's business is closed by official order pursuant to Section 28 (1) sentences 1 and 2 of the IfSG, the principle that the employer bears the entrepreneurial economic risk may be deviated from in exceptional cases. Extreme emergency situations such as wars, riots, and terrorist attacks are excluded from the economic risk. It is controversial whether epidemics are also covered by this. In such an exceptional situation, the claim for remuneration pursuant to Section 615 sentence 3 of the BGB may not exist.
This constellation occurs, for example, when the kindergarten is temporarily closed due to the coronavirus and you have to organize childcare yourself, making it impossible for you to fulfill your work obligations.
You may still be entitled to a claim for wages in accordance with Section 616 of the German Civil Code (BGB) due to a temporary inability to work, for a period of up to five days. Please note, however, that this provision can be contractually excluded; if the application of Section 616 BGB is excluded in your employment contract, your employer is not obligated to provide continued wage payment according to this provision. Furthermore, you would not be entitled to sick pay for the care or illness of your child in accordance with Section 44a(3) of the German Social Code Book XI (SGB XI) or Section 45 SGB, as your child is neither sick nor in need of care.
Pursuant to §§ 618, 241 para. 2 BGB, your employer has labor law protection obligations, particularly the duty to protect the health of his employees. In this case, he must, among other things, ensure compliance with hygiene standards. Furthermore, as previously explained, ordering home office or, if applicable, paid leave of absence is an option. The decisive factor for this decision is the employer's right of direction according to § 106 GewO; an order from the employer must be in accordance with reasonable discretion and adequately consider the interests of his employees. Should there be (objective) indications of concrete endangerment or risk of infection within the company, the employer may release individual employees, at least on a short-term basis. If the employer is aware of the illness, he must send the (sick) employee home – both with regard to the well-being of the sick person and the healthy employees.
If you suspect that another employee is infected (e.g., because they are coughing or showing other signs of illness), you may, under strict conditions, have a right to withhold your labor according to § 275(3) of the German Civil Code (BGB). This is the case if it cannot be reasonably expected of you to fulfill your contractual employment obligations. If circumstances exist that justify the assumption of an increased risk of infection by a colleague, a right to withhold labor may potentially be established. However, please note that you should always attempt to reach an amicable and, in particular, mutually beneficial solution with your employer to rule out the risk of a warning or termination.
A comprehensive balancing of the interests of both parties (employer and employee) is also required here, as instructions may be given at the employer's reasonable discretion in accordance with Section 106 of the Commercial Code (GewO). Essentially, the explanations under point 1 apply here.
Where there is a factually justified assumption of a high risk of infection, you may refuse your employer's instructions; in this case, your physical integrity has absolute priority. Therefore, you would be entitled to a right of retention pursuant to § 275 para. 3 of the German Civil Code (BGB). Please note that not every abstract danger justifies a right of retention. If the alleged danger does not go beyond the general risks of life, refusal to perform work is not justified.
The question of whether you are obligated to inform your employer about whether you are ill or what you are ill with is governed by Section 26, Paragraph 1, Sentences 1 and 3 of the BDSG (Federal Data Protection Act) in conjunction with Article 9 of the GDPR.
Hereafter, your employer may process your personal data (including health data within the meaning of Art. 9(1) GDPR) if this is necessary for the performance of the employment relationship.
According to § 5 EFZG, you are obliged to inform your employer (immediately) that you are ill. However, you do not have to tell them what you are ill with. Your employer does not have the right to ask about this. If you have recently been in a particularly high-risk area (e.g., for vacation purposes) or an area for which the Federal Foreign Office has issued an official travel warning due to the risk of infection, and there is a fear that you may have become infected, it is up to you to inform your employer of this (voluntarily). Following this, your employer may temporarily relieve you of your duties – with continued payment of your salary – if necessary, or take other measures to protect other employees.
If needed, please feel free to contact us so that we can advise you individually on the introduction or implementation of labor law measures or questions.
The coronavirus crisis presents a challenge for both employers and employees.
Therefore, our team of specialized lawyers is fully available to you during this difficult time.
Simply log in at Phone. +49 6151 – 99 55 0 or send us a message about the Contact Form.
We will take on your case promptly and advise you purposefully.