Parental consent for publishing children's photos

 
 
 

 

 

 


Vacation photos, everyday snapshots, videos from swimming pool visits or starting school – children are often the subject of numerous, sometimes advertising-effective, staged photos or displays on social media platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and others by their parents. However, the publication of children's photos on social networks has significant consequences for child development.

Parents are often unaware of the implications of publishing sensitive photos of their children online. The unintentional accessibility to a large number of people or the difficulty of deleting the images from the internet repeatedly pose a problem. Children generally deserve special protection, including in the area of data protection. In July 2021, the Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf dealt with the question of whether the consent of both parents is required for the publication of children's photos when they share custody.

 


The most important things in brief:

  • The use of photographs is subject to the consent requirement of Article 6(1) sentence 1(a) of the GDPR.
    Consent for the publication of images must be obtained from the parents as „persons with parental responsibility“ according to Article 8(1) Sentence 2 GDPR, as long as the child has not yet reached the age of 16.

  • If a decision is of „considerable importance“ for the child within the meaning of Section 1687 (1) Sentence 1 of the German Civil Code (BGB), the mutual consent of the parents is required, provided they are permanently separated.

  • According to § 22 KUG, the child's consent may also be required if the child is capable of making decisions in the individual case according to their level of development.



Background of the court's decision

The decision of the Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf was based on the question of whether the consent of both parents is necessary for the publication of children's photos, or whether the consent of only one parent with custody is sufficient.

The married couple in question lives separately but both have custody rights. The child's father's new life partner currently operates a hair salon. As part of advertising and marketing efforts, the partner took pictures of the children for her hair salon business and published them on her Facebook and Instagram pages. The photos showed the daughters getting their hair cut. The father agreed to this publication, but the biological mother did not.

Any demands by the biological mother to cease publication of the images and to delete already uploaded images failed. The cease and desist declaration previously sent to the girlfriend for signature also went unheeded. Likewise, the biological father refused to support his (still) wife's request. Instead, further recordings of the children were published on the girlfriend's social media platforms.



Consent requirement for publishing children's photos

In particular, due to the trend of uploading children's images to relevant social platforms for media attention, the global dissemination possibility within seconds, and the dangers of making children's images unfiltered accessible to a broad audience, attention is drawn here to data protection legal obstacles and issues.

Fundamentally, the use of images is subject to the consent requirement of Art. 6(1) sentence 1 lit. a) GDPR. According to this, the processing of photos is only lawful if the data subject has given their consent to the processing.

Pursuant to Article 8(1) sentence 1 of the GDPR, minors are capable of consenting once they have reached the age of 16. According to Article 8(1) sentence 2 of the GDPR, any processing of an image of a child who has not yet reached the age of 16 is lawful „if and to the extent that consent is given by, or authoriased by, the holder of parental responsibility over the child.“ Consequently, consent is subject to the stipulation that the parent with custody must give their consent.

In the present case, the parents live permanently separated but share custody. According to German custody law, it is particularly important in such a constellation whether the matter concerns daily life or a decision of significant importance for the child. If the event is considered a daily matter, according to § 1687 (1) sentence 2 of the German Civil Code (BGB), the decision on publishing the pictures would fall to the parent with whom the child ordinarily resides. However, if it is a decision of significant importance, according to § 1687 (1) sentence 1 BGB, the mutual agreement of the custodians, i.e., both parents, must be obtained.

It must therefore be examined whether the threshold of significance within the meaning of Section 1628 of the German Civil Code (BGB) is exceeded in the individual case and whether any publication has implications for the child's development.

Furthermore, the consent of the child itself may also be required. According to Section 22 of the KUG, portraits may only be published with the consent of the person depicted. In the case of minors who are themselves capable of consenting, the consent of the parents is therefore no longer sufficient. Rather, children who are capable of consenting can themselves consent. When this capacity to consent exists must be decided in each individual case, taking into account the respective developmental stage of the child concerned.



Procedure and Court Decision

Initially, the mother of the children applied for an interim order before the Düsseldorf Local Court (AG) as a result of her estranged husband and his partner refusing to refrain from publishing pictures of the children. The AG heard the mother and granted her sole custody for out-of-court and in-court disputes with the partner. However, the AG Düsseldorf did not hear the biological father. Following the AG's order, the partner removed the photos from her social media appearances. Nevertheless, the father of the two daughters considered his right to be heard violated and appealed to the Düsseldorf Higher Regional Court (OLG). According to his statement, the children's photos, in his opinion, show everyday normality that would not harm his children's personalities in any way and therefore his consent would suffice.

Ultimately, the Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf ruled in favor of the child's welfare and thus for a requirement of consent from both parents. The judges assessed the publication of the child images in question as highly sensitive, so that they ultimately considered the threshold of significance of § 1628 BGB to have been exceeded. The court stated that the public sharing of the images on social media has impacts on the child's development that are difficult to alter. This was due to the scope of distribution of photos on digital social media, considering the children's privacy affected thereby and the necessary protection of their personality. The group of people to whom the photos are made accessible in this way is unlimited. Their further dissemination is difficult to control. Reliable deletion of the images is not possible.

Furthermore, the court is of the opinion that children could potentially remain confronted with images from their childhood by an unrestricted group of people forever.

Insofar as this, the publication of the images on the internet is to be classified as a „decision of considerable importance for the child“ within the meaning of § 1628 BGB. Therefore, the consent of only one parent, in this case the child's father, is not sufficient for such a decision according to § 1687 (1) sentence 1 BGB. The mutual agreement of both parents is required.

Furthermore, the publication of the photograph is also inadmissible under Section 22, Sentence 3 and Sentence 4 of the KUG, as such a measure requires the consent of both parents due to the child's inability to consent.

The Düsseldorf Local Court did not accept the father's objection that his estranged wife and the children's grandmother had also posted photos of the children online without his consent. For the present proceedings, only the specific case and the respective specific unlawful processing of images were decisive. The subject matter is exclusively the dissemination of images of the children by the father's partner and the resulting dispute. No generally valid consent for future publications can be derived from prior behavior.

The court set the appeal value at 2,000 Euros.

 

Outlook

Children are particularly vulnerable and deserve special protection. Digital threats of the 21st century, such as the use of social networks, the possibility of parents disseminating sensitive images to an unlimited audience, and the later possibility of being confronted with unwelcome images, are often ignored and disregarded. However, caution is also advised here, because „the welfare of the child requires that the dissemination of child images on digital social media respects the relevant legal consent requirements, which primarily aim to protect the child's personality.“

If the consent of both parents is not present, the publication of the photos is unlawful. The child or the parent who did not consent to the publication can then demand the deletion of the photos as well as the future cessation of such publications according to § 1004 paragraph 1 sentence 2 BGB in conjunction with §§ 823 paragraph 2 BGB, 22, 23 KUG.

So, if you use images of children for advertising and marketing purposes, you should always obtain all necessary consents from the individuals involved. When staging photographs, the welfare of the child and the potential impact of publishing the specific image on the child's development must always be kept in mind.

 

Get in touch