Article 28 lists the requirements and regulations for contract processing.
Order processing refers to outsourcing the processing of user data to an external third party through a processing agreement.
The most important things at a glance
- In a data processing order, the controller does not carry out the data processing themselves
- The data processing agreement can be concluded in electronic form pursuant to Section 126b of the German Civil Code (BGB).
- Order processing can also take place in a non-EU country
- As long as the processor follows the controller's instructions, the controller is liable
1. When is it referred to as order processing?
If other persons are involved in data processing besides the data controller, this could constitute contract processing.
If the processing person acts solely in the interest of the responsible party and the responsible party is also the client, it is usually a commissioned processing.
A processing agreement must have been concluded before the commencement of instructed actions.
The cases of contract processing are diverse. For example, storing data via a cloud provider can be contract processing. A third party can also be contractually appointed for contract processing.
Whether order processing is involved must be assessed on a case-by-case basis.
2. The Processing Agreement
For effective order processing, a processing agreement must be concluded. According to Art. 28(3) GDPR, the contract must include the following points:
- Processor's Binding regarding the Controller's Instructions
- Subject and duration of processing
- Type and purpose of processing
- Type of personal data
- Categories of affected persons
- Defining the responsibilities and rights of the person in charge
Many essential aspects of the BDSG have also been incorporated into the GDPR.
However, compared to the BDSG, there is a new feature in the contract between the controller and the processor:
According to Art. 28(9) GDPR, such a contract can now be concluded not only in writing, but also electronically.
In practice, the new regulation affects not only the conclusion of contracts but also the cancellation policy.
This must also be carried out when concluding contracts electronically and must be provided in an unchanged state permanently. It is therefore advised to transmit the file as a PDF and/or make it available for download.
3. Obligations of the Order Processor
Abs. 3 (1) lit. a) – h) regulates the obligations of the contract processor.
For one, there are documentation and evidence requirements. The processor must be able to prove that they followed the instructions of the controller and acted within the scope of the GDPR regulations.
Regarding personal data, there is a strict duty of confidentiality.
In addition, security measures must be taken, appropriate technical and organizational measures must be established, and the provisions of the GDPR must be complied with.
Once the activity is terminated, the processor must return or delete all versions of personal data. Deletion may only occur if no tax, commercial, or Union law requires storage.
4. Liability in the Event of a GDPR Violation
Pursuant to Article 4(7) of the GDPR, the controller, acting alone or jointly with others, determines the purposes and means of the processing of personal data. The controller is responsible for ensuring compliance with the provisions of the Regulation and is liable in the event of a breach.
The processor, on the other hand, processes personal data only on behalf of the controller in accordance with Article 4(8) of the GDPR.
As previously mentioned, he is bound by instructions and makes few to no independent decisions within the scope of his assigned tasks.
If the processor acts as intended according to the controller's instructions and steps into their obligations, the controller must account for and be liable for any errors.
This is different when the processor acts contrary to the agreements between them and the controller, thus defying the client's instructions.
In these cases, Article 28(10) GDPR applies: The processor is considered the controller because it violates the regulation and determines the purposes and means of the processing itself, and must therefore also be liable as such.
5. Conclusion
Art. 28 GDPR addresses some aspects that were already enshrined in the German Federal Data Protection Act (BDSG). Modernizations were made in the area of the form of concluding the processing agreement. Since the introduction of the GDPR, the agreement can now also be concluded in electronic form.
In summary, Article 28 GDPR also facilitates the outsourcing of data processing to a processor while emphasizing and ensuring data protection.
As a rule, Article 28 GDPR does not give rise to liability issues, even if multiple actors are involved.
Nevertheless, each individual case must be considered and assessed on its own merits.
The standard is highly relevant in practice and should be implemented according to the specifications.